Don’t let fear get in the way of facts when it comes to changing Supplement companies or letter plans.

Question:

Question from Patty: My husband and I are both 78 years old and have had Plan F Supplements since we turned 65. We love the coverage, but the premiums are now over $800/month, and we have another rate increase coming in March. My husband went through cancer 10 years ago and everything was paid in full. We’re afraid if we change companies and have another serious health issue, we wouldn’t be covered the same. How would my coverage change if we moved to another company or letter plan? 

Answer:

I have news for Patty and the millions of people who are afraid to move to another Supplement company or letter plan. When Patty’s husband had cancer and his scans, biopsies, surgery, and chemo or radiation were paid in full, it wasn’t because the company he has now did anything special or Plan F is “the best.” The company was just following the regulations set forth by Medicare in regard to Supplement (aka Medigap) policies, and Plans G and N combined with Medicare would have paid for all the same services in full as well.  

Letter plans G and N, and all companies who offer them, cover the same medical services and provide the same access to doctors and hospitals all over the country just like Plan F.  And as importantly, regardless of company or letter plan, and why we recommend Supplements so much, there are no prior authorizations necessary, nor can there be any insurance company interference when services such as MRIs, CT scans, surgeries, chemo, physical therapy, etc., are needed. 

In addition, Supplement companies have no say in what’s covered. That’s all determined by Medicare who lets your treating physician decide what’s medically necessary.  And when Medicare approves and pays their share of the claim, the Supplement company must pay theirs, by law, no questions asked. In fact, medical providers don’t even bill Supplement companies. They bill only Medicare, who then coordinates with whatever Supplement company the patient has to get the doctor or hospital paid in full.

What I’m saying here, and what I’ve been repeating for 20 years, is the name of a Supplement company means absolutely nothing. They’re all created equal. And F isn’t some magic plan that’s worth tens of thousands of dollars more than G or N. Here’s an excerpt from page 6 Medicare’s official 2026 publication called, Choosing a Medigap (Supplement) Policy: “Medigap policies must follow federal and state laws designed to protect you, and they must be clearly identified as Medicare Supplement Insurance. Insurance companies can only sell you standardized plans, which are named in most states by letters A through N. “All plans with the same letter offer the same basic benefits, no matter where you live or which insurance company you buy the policy from. Price is the only difference between policies with the same letter sold by different companies.” And when it comes to letter Plans F, G, and N, again, there’s also no difference in what services are covered! 

Patty and her husband can both pass medical underwriting and there are no circumstances where staying on Plan F is a smart choice. Patty and her husband can move to Plan G and pay just $380 per month total, a savings of over $5,000 annually! Plan N would only be $273 per month and would save them more than $6,300 per year! And that’s before the $100/month increase they have coming in January! 

I’d like to add that we rarely recommend Plan G because we feel it’s also antiquated and overpriced. Patty and her husband can save $1,300 per year by choosing N over G. With just a very small reduction in out-of-pocket costs, G doesn’t offer anywhere near $1,300 per year in value. 

Here’s a more shocking dollar figure. Over the next 10 years, if Patty and her husband chose G instead of N and there’s the same 12% annual increase on both, they will pay $23,000 more in premiums than they would have on N! This is why we encourage anyone who currently has Plan G to move to Plan N as soon as possible and while you still can. 

People on Supplements need to understand the facts, rules, and regulations regarding these polices as well the very small and inconsequential differences between letter Plans C, F, G, and N. Stop letting fear or bad information influence decisions that can cost literally tens of thousands of dollars over the next 5 to 10 years. 

Give us a call with questions or to schedule a no-cost consultation, 724-603-3403. Feel free to email me personally as well. Aaron@GetYourBestPlan.com. 

Join our Facebook Group

Join our “Ask the Medicare Specialist” Facebook Group to stay up to date with the latest information on Medicare.

Scroll to Top