This week’s questions from Julie
I’m on a plan that’s rated four and a half stars. I’m looking at the 2023 Medicare and You Handbook I just got in the mail and see many plans get five stars. What does that mean for me? Should I change to a five-star plan?
Answer
It is Likely Not Worth Changing
No. Changing to a five-star plan for the sake of having that designation alone gets you no better benefits, privileges, or coverage. I don’t like the way stars are awarded because monthly premiums, cost of co-pays, the Maximum out of Pocket (MOOP), and amount and generosity of ancillary benefits like dental, vision, hearing, OTC allowances, etc., are not taken into consideration at all! That’s very misleading for consumers in my opinion.
For example, there’s a 2022 five-star plan that has a premium over $70/month, a five-day hospital co-pay of over $1,000, a MOOP over $5,000, offers no comprehensive dental or OTC allowances, and provides only $150 for eyeglasses. Meanwhile, another 2022 plan in our market costs under $30/month, has a 5-day hospital co-pay under $300, a MOOP that’s $1,000 less, provides more than $2,000 in comprehensive dental, the best OTC and hearing benefits in the market, $250 additional eyeglasses allowance, and a debit card that helps pay as much as $400/year for certain co-pays. It only gets four and a half stars.
Never Choose Based on Name
You should never choose a Medicare plan based solely on what health insurance company you currently have or how long you’ve been a member. These are two of the biggest and most common mistakes people make. The company you referred to, which I’m not able to name, has some very competitive plans that will be getting even better in 2023. They also have the best member services department in the industry, which is something to be considered in a final decision. It’s not the most important aspect, however, especially for clients of The Health Insurance Store because we get involved in helping if there are ever any issues, questions, or concerns regarding their plan, bills, claim denials, etc. The plan you mentioned is an Advantage Plan, not a Supplement and the most critical element to any decision of what Medicare plan you initially choose is understanding the differences between both prior to enrolling. The decision you make when going on Part B for the first time can have a lifetime of consequences.
How the Stars are Achieved
According to Xtelligent Healthcare Media, “CMS (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid) assesses a Medicare Advantage plan’s quality of care according to the plan’s performance on a list of quality measures. Each measure falls under one of nine domains. The domains include maintaining health, chronic disease management, member experience, member complaints, and customer service as well as four domains for scoring drug plans. Thus, measures could include annual flu vaccination, diabetes care—eye exam, rating of health care quality, members choosing to leave the plan, reviewing appeals decisions, and more.”
It’s important to note, “As part of pandemic relief, CMS relaxed how it calculated Medicare Advantage star ratings for 2021 and 2022. The result was a record number of insurers gaining higher scores on the program’s five-point scale, and a corresponding increase in federal spending on bonuses.” This is according to Modern Healthcare, which I subscribe to and rely heavily on for breaking news and trends in the healthcare and health insurance industries. They go on to explain that “Medicare Advantage carriers are prepping for the most difficult star ratings season since before the pandemic. The CMS is set to resume the standard process for assessing quality, which it relaxed in response to the public health crisis (COVID), and to more heavily weigh consumer satisfaction when determining health plan performance. These looming changes threaten the big bonuses on which insurers came to rely on to differentiate their offerings in the crowded market for private Medicare plans through richer benefits and lower premiums.” To summarize, many plans that were awarded five stars would not have earned them if it weren’t for the fact CMS stopped taking member complaints and satisfaction into account.
What I Expect for Ratings in the Future
There are two things I expect to happen due to the more stringent star rating system; There will be fewer, if any, five-star plans when those ratings come out in 2023 or 2024. Another ramification that I’m extremely concerned about is plans which fall under four stars will lose the five percent bonus they’ve been receiving. This extra money companies have been paid is the reason more ancillary benefits as well as lower overall premiums and co-pays have been offered on their best plans. If they lose that bonus and it has a substantial impact on profit margins which I would expect, we may see the outstanding value Advantage Plans have offered in the last couple of years and into 2023, be reduced in 2024, 2025, and beyond. This could mean less generous dental, vision, hearing, and OTC allowances and/or higher co-pays and premiums. I’m hopeful that a moratorium on the reduced reimbursements will be announced so there isn’t any shock to the system. By January 1st, 2023, there will be more than 30 million Americans who rely on Advantage Plans due to the lower premiums and extra benefits they provide.
You can make a difference in star ratings because part of what goes into them is the number of members who get their preventative services such as mammograms, prostate screenings, flu and pneumonia vaccines, and others. And those calls constantly asking you to let a nurse come to the house for a health assessment? The percentage of members who participate is also important to star ratings. Make sure you receive all your preventative services and schedule your home health assessment! Not only will it help your plan keep its 4 plus star rating and great benefits, but it also can contribute to good health. I actually had a client tell me a serious medical issue was diagnosed by a nurse during his home visit that may have saved his life.
AEP is right around the corner!
I’d like to remind readers that the Annual Election Period (AEP) is right around the corner. Pre AEP, when plan details are made public, starts October 1st and AEP, when changes to your plan lineup can be made and applications submitted, begins October 15th and runs through December 7th.
If you enjoy the columns, please consider using our no cost services when going on Medicare for the first time or looking at possibly making a change in plans as well as referring friends or family who are. Enrolling new clients in plans, which cost the same whether you use our free services or go directly through a company, helps us cover the expense of the articles so we can continue to run them every week. As brokers, we are appointed to provide plans from every competitive Advantage Plan and Supplement company in Western PA and West Virginia.
Thank you!
If you have any questions or concerns regarding this column topic, or would like to make an appointment for a no-cost consultation, please feel free to give us a call – we would be happy to help. I’d like to remind everyone that I do a live call-in talk show called Medicare A to Z every 1st and 3rd Monday of the month on WMBS Uniontown, 590AM and 101.1FM, from 1 to 3 PM. You can listen in on their website, wmbs590.com.
Erie County Area
1105 West 12th Street, Suite – A
Erie, PA 16501
Phone: 814-920-5275
Fax: 814-920-5276
Fayette/Westmoreland County Area
121 North Pittsburgh Street
Connellsville, PA. 15425
Phone: 724-603-3403
Fax: 724-603-3402
Pittsburgh Area
21 Yost Blvd., Forest Hills, PA 15221
Mailing Address: 128 Forest Hills Plaza, Pittsburgh, PA 15221
Phone: 412-349-8818
Fax: 878-302-3149
Albuquerque/Santa Fe, New Mexico Area
821 Coors Blvd. NW
Albuquerque, NM 87121
Phone: 505-200-0069
Fax: 505-200-0073
Serving These Areas
We proudly serve the health insurance and Medicare needs of the following Pennsylvania areas: Connellsville, Uniontown, Greensburg, Mt. Pleasant, Scottdale, Irwin, N. Huntingdon, Murrysville, Monroeville, Plum, Lower Burrell, New Kensington, Pittsburgh, Plum, Oakmont, Penn Hills, Forest Hills, Wilkinsburg, East Liberty, Lawrenceville, Bloomfield, Natrona Heights, Leechburg, Washington, Morgantown WV, Latrobe, Monnessen, Jeanette, Erie, Edinboro, Northeast, Girard, Fairview, Union City, Harborcreek, Corey, Meadville, Waterford, Ligonier, Kittaning, Somerset, Waynesburg, Fayette County, Westmoreland County, Armstrong County, Butler County, Somerset County, Erie County, Crawford County, Venango County, Allegheny Valley, Pennsylvania
We proudly serve the following New Mexico areas: Albuquerque, Rio Rancho, Sante Fe, Bernalillo, Belen, Los Lunas, Espanola, Moriarty, Corales, Tijeras, Cedar Crest, Edgewood, Soccoro, Sandoval County, Sante Fe County, Bernalillo County, Rio Arriba County, Valencia County, Soccoro County, New Mexico
Not affiliated with the U. S. government or federal Medicare program.
We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE to get information on all of your options.